Dear Roxanne,
I've read every column since you started and I am close to making a move on an Italian share. My daughter, who is a lawyer, asked me one question I couldn't answer. How do you get out? Not because I plan to, she said, but because that's the question that tells you what a thing really is. So, I'm asking you. When we want to sell, what actually happens?
Sincerely,
Cautious in Oakville
Dear Cautious,
Your daughter asked the right question.
Here is the plain answer. You can sell. A share is property. It is yours to sell, and yours to leave to your children. What I can't tell you is that it will be quick.
Expect months rather than weeks. This runs on a home's timeline, and anyone who may need the money back in a fortnight has bought the wrong thing entirely.
Two things decide how the sale goes. The first is how the home is owned. Where a company owns the house and you hold shares of that company, selling means transferring shares, which is usually faster and cheaper than a property sale. Where your name sits on the title alongside the other owners, you sell the way property is sold in that country, with the notary, the costs and the paperwork that implies. Neither is better. They simply behave differently on the day you want out, and you should know which one you are buying.
The second is the home itself. A share in a Paris apartment will find its buyer sooner than a share in a beautiful house an hour from anywhere. Charm and a quick sale are different qualities, and the homes that stir you most are not always the ones that go first.
Now the part I would want said to me. The European fractional resale market is young. There is no long record of sales I can lay in front of you, the way I can tell you what a street in Oakville did last year.
So before you sign, ask for four things in writing:
● The resale clause. Who runs the sale, and whether the operator or your co-owners have first refusal.
● The resale fee. There usually is one. Get the number.
● The operator's actual resale history. How many shares have resold, at what prices, and how long each one took. Ask for all of them, not the good ones.
● Whether your contract carries a right to withdraw after signing. European consumer rules give buyers a 14-day withdrawal right on certain holiday-property contracts,
and whether yours qualifies depends on how it is written. Your lawyer should confirm it rather than the person selling to you.
Send me what comes back and I will go through it with you. Have your daughter read it as well.
One last thought. Buy for a decade of use and the exit becomes the end of a chapter instead of an escape. If you find yourself planning the sale before you have booked a single week, listen to that. Some worries are advisors.
Roxanne
Have a question about owning a piece of Europe? Write to me at [email protected]. Letters may be edited and appear with a pen name. And when you're ready to see the homes themselves, the Portico International door is open; signing up takes a moment.
Roxanne Finn is a broker with Chestnut Park Real Estate Limited, Brokerage, in Stratford. She acts as a referring realtor; partner companies are independent, and buyers should obtain independent legal advice in the destination country. Co-ownership is a lifestyle purchase. Nothing here is legal, tax or immigration advice.




